Over-Reliance on Tooltips

Vibe Check – The Problem with Over-Reliance on Tooltips: Why Essential Content Shouldn’t Be Hidden Behind Hover States

Tooltips can be useful for providing additional information, but when essential content is locked behind hover states, accessibility and usability suffer. Many designers assume tooltips enhance clarity, but in reality, they often create unnecessary barriers—especially for people who use keyboards, screen readers, or touch devices.

Let’s dive into why over-relying on tooltips can be problematic and how to design better alternatives.

Personal Story – A Missing Explanation That Was There All Along

I was once testing an interface that had a set of confusing symbols. None of them had visible labels, and clicking them didn’t provide any obvious feedback. Frustrated, I switched to a screen reader to see if there were any hidden cues—and that’s when I discovered the issue. The missing explanations were buried inside tooltips that only appeared when hovered over with a mouse.

The problem? People who use keyboards couldn’t easily access them. People who use touchscreens had no way to trigger them. And people who use screen readers wouldn’t know the tooltips existed unless they happened to stumble upon them. This experience reinforced an important lesson: if information is essential, it should always be visible or easily accessible—not hidden behind an unpredictable interaction.

Elevate the Vibe – Why Relying on Tooltips Causes Accessibility Issues

Tooltips are often treated as a quick fix for explaining design elements, but they introduce major usability problems when used incorrectly.

1) Tooltips Are Inaccessible for Keyboard Navigation

The Problem:

• Many tooltips require a hover action, which isn’t possible with a keyboard.
• People using a keyboard often get no indication that a tooltip exists.
• Even when tooltips are focusable, they might disappear too quickly, making them hard to read.

Fix It: Ensure tooltips are accessible via keyboard focus and don’t disappear immediately when focus is moved.

2) Tooltips Don’t Work Well on Touchscreens

The Problem:

• On mobile devices and tablets, there is no hover state.
• Some touch interfaces use a “long press” to trigger tooltips, but this isn’t intuitive or widely known.
• Important information gets completely lost for people using touch devices.

Fix It: If information is critical, display it inline or make it accessible via a tap action rather than relying on hover.

3) Screen Readers Don’t Always Detect Tooltips

The Problem:

• Many tooltips aren’t properly coded with ARIA attributes, meaning screen readers ignore them.
• People navigating with screen readers may never know additional information is available.
• If a tooltip is tied to an inaccessible <div> instead of a properly labeled button or link, it won’t be announced.

Fix It: Use ARIA attributes like aria-describedby to link tooltips to their relevant elements and ensure people using screen readers are notified.

4) Tooltips Can Increase Cognitive Load

The Problem:

• When too much information is packed into a tooltip, people are forced to read and retain it quickly before it disappears.
• If people need to reference the tooltip multiple times, they must repeatedly hover over the element, disrupting their workflow.

Fix It: Avoid relying on tooltips for crucial instructions—place key information within the visible interface.

5) Auto-Dismissing Tooltips Cause Frustration

The Problem:

• Some tooltips disappear too quickly, especially when people accidentally move their mouse or shift focus.
• This forces people to repeatedly hover, making information retrieval frustrating and inefficient.

Fix It: Allow tooltips to remain visible until dismissed or when focus moves away deliberately.

Vibe Boost – How to Design Without Over-Reliance on Tooltips

1) Make Essential Information Visible

• Instead of hiding field instructions in tooltips, place them below or next to the input field.
• Ensure button labels provide clear descriptions instead of relying solely on symbols.

2) Use Tooltips as Enhancements, Not Requirements

• Tooltips should add context, not be the only way to understand an element.
• Ensure that removing tooltips doesn’t make the interface unusable.

3) Ensure Tooltips Are Keyboard and Screen Reader Accessible

• Use aria-describedby to connect tooltips to elements.
• Make tooltips focusable and ensure they remain visible while people navigate them.

4) Consider Alternative Design Patterns

• Inline Text: If the information is important, show it directly on the page.
• Expandable Sections: Use toggles to reveal additional details when needed.
• Contextual Help Labels: Place text-based descriptions next to elements for better clarity.

Self-Reflection – Evaluating Your Use of Tooltips

Ask yourself:

• Is this tooltip providing essential information that should always be visible?
• Can people navigate my tooltips with a keyboard?
• Will touchscreen people miss out on this content?
• Are tooltips the only way people can understand an interaction?

If the answer to any of these is yes, it’s time to rethink your approach!

Vibe in Action – Making Interfaces More Usable Without Tooltips

1) Apply What You’ve Learned

• Audit your design to identify tooltips that hide essential information.
• Replace tooltip-dependent instructions with visible alternatives.

2) Share the Knowledge

• Educate your design and development teams on tooltip accessibility issues.
• Advocate for designs that prioritize clarity without relying on hover states.

3) Keep Learning

• Follow WCAG guidelines on tooltips and interactive elements.
• Conduct usability testing to see where tooltips cause friction for people.

Vibing Out

Tooltips should enhance usability, not hinder it. When designers over-rely on hover-based interactions, they unintentionally exclude people who navigate differently. Instead of hiding critical content, we should ensure information is available to everyone, regardless of how they interact with a site.

Let’s move past designs that require people to “find” information and create experiences where clarity is built-in from the start. Because when accessibility is prioritized, everyone benefits.

‍